"I can't choose," you say, "because I want to do them all! I love you and I want you to be all mine!"
She moans at that and starts moving a little faster on your dick. "Yes, but which one first?" she manages to get out through her moans.
"Pussy!" You roar as you thrust up into her hard and start cumming. "Right now!"
She squeals in her own orgasm as she feels you splashing at the opening to her fertile womb. "Oh, Maxxxxxxxxxxxxx! I love you tooooo!"
You both shudder for a few more seconds as your respective orgasms wash over you. After you are both finished, Sam slumps back against your chest and gently pets her pussy and the part of you that is still outside. "That was wonderful," she says. "We really REALLY shouldn't have done that. But surprisingly I have no regrets. I don't know when it started, but I really do love you and whatever you want to do is just fine with me." She stands up and stretches languidly in front of you, uncaring that your cum is starting to ooze out of her pussy and down her leg.
She turns and looks at you. "So which do you want next? Mouth? Ass? More pussy in another position?"
When you hesitate, she smiles and says, "Just tell me. Whatever you want, I said and I meant it."
"In that case, kneel down and clean my penis and then make me cum."
She grins. "I knew you were going to say that," she says as she kneels down. Just like she didn't care that your cum was running down her leg, she doesn't care that your cock is slimy with your combined juices and she pops it into her mouth without any squeamishness.
You lightly rest your hand on her head and softly caress her red hair as she bobs up and down, popping you in and out of her mouth as she licks and sucks the juices off.
"That's my good girl," you whisper. Apparently she heard you because she "mmmmm's" around your cock which is deep in her mouth at that moment.
She pops it out just long enough to say, "Yes, I am. All yours."
"All mine," you say a little louder, still in slight disbelief that your oldest sister has so totally flipped her attitude around to be your willing woman.
Your cock must be clean of your juices because she has stopped licking and is just sucking now. You ask, "So do you want to finish this yourself or do you want me to fuck your mouth?"
"Whatever you want, I said," she replies. She looks up at me as if to say "I dare you."
Well, if that's the way she wants it...you stand up and hold the sides of her head. She puts her hands calmly on her thighs and looks up at you trustingly. You start moving in and out of her mouth as if you were fucking. You're doing it gently but it's clear that you're in charge here and the thought is so arousing that you quickly approach orgasm.
You decide to let it happen and you thrust to completion and cum in Sam's relaxed mouth. She swallows it all down without hesitation.
You withdraw from her mouth and lift her up to her feet. She smiles at you and you two kiss gently. She looks around and finds some discarded panties then wipes your cum from her legs and throws them into her laundry basket. She fist-pumps as she makes the shot. "Score!" she says then giggles.
You smile at her while watching her tits jiggle. She then climbs onto the bed and holds her arms out to you. "Come on and let's cuddle until you're ready for my ass."
Just the sheer sexiness of her behavior and her saying I'm going to take her ass causes you to react and you know it won't be long. But you lie down anyway and take her in your arms.
You kiss her again and whisper, "I don't know what it was that really changed your mind about all this and I don't care at the moment because I know I'll find out eventually. I just want you to know I meant what I said - I love you. I don't need to take your ass right away - just the fact that you'll let me take it eventually means a lot to me."
"Oh, that's so sweet," Sam coos. "But you ARE going to get the unassisted triple play today."
You two both laugh at the sports reference - she played softball in high school, naturally, along with several other sports - but hers is more of a giggle. You're strangely happy to see it as she hasn't been this carefree around you in quite some time. The fact that she's now so comfortable with you that she'll let her hair down completely, so to speak, hits you hard and you fall even more in love with her.
You look over at the clock and to your surprise it's approaching dinnertime. You mention that fact to her and ask if she wants to stop for now or lose her third cherry before dinner.
She realizes you're leaving it up to her so she gives it some serious thought for a few seconds. "Now," she says. "I'll already be walking funny so let's go all the way. I'm feeling rather kinky tonight and I don't care if everyone else sees me walking funny. I'm sure they'll find out eventually, anyway, and I just don't care. I'd almost rather everyone knows right away that I'm your woman."
You shrug. You halfway expected this because her general attitude her whole life has been to "just do it" instead of dithering over it. "Okay, then, since we don't have a whole lot of time, why don't you give it some help," you say as you back away and gently pull Sam's head towards your cock.
She smiles as she realizes what you mean and she gently but insistently pushes you onto your back and takes you in her mouth once again. A few minutes of sucking successfully produces another erection and she pops it out of her mouth with a victorious smile.
"So how do you want me?" she asks.
"Hands and knees," you say as you wave for her to turn around.
She spins around quickly and is facing away from you. She looks over her shoulder and wiggles her ass at you as she reaches back with both hands and spreads her ass cheeks. "Go ahead. Take my third cherry, Max. Make me all yours."
You nod, your eyes already on her back passage which has been clearly revealed by her hands. You place your wet erection right at her opening and slowly but steadily push into it. It resists at first but she does something to relax it and the first inch or so pops in before you can stop.
She squeals and lets go of her ass as she clenches her fists and shuts her eyes in discomfort and you wait for a minute or so before she opens her eyes again and nods at you. "Go ahead."
You resume your slow and steady pushing and soon enough your hips are right against her butt.
"Oh, God," she whispers. "You're really inside my ass, Max. I thought it would feel differently. And, well, it kind of does - different than my pussy, I mean. But it feels good, too. Just a different kind of good. Wow." She pauses, then continues. "I think we'll be doing this again, for sure. But we can't do it 'again' until we finish the first time, so get busy, buster." Despite her last words sounding a little abrupt, in fact her voice is soft and loving.
You start moving back and forth inside Sam's warmly clasping ass. You had wondered if you would take a long time in her ass because it was the third time in a short period of time or if the idea, the thought of you being in your oldest sister's most taboo place would make you cum quickly. Your reaction, however, tells you that it's going to be fast. Not as fast as her mouth was, however, so you sternly tell yourself not to hurry this. You won't have another chance at your very first triple play, after all, so you resolve to make it last as long as you can.
You move in and out of her steadily at a moderate pace. Soon enough she's huffing and puffing as she mumbles, "So good. So good. Didn't think I'd cum this way but I'm going to...I'm going to...I AM!"
When she comes, her ass clenches so tightly around you that you can't move, not without risking hurting her, so you just stop. You bend over her so that you're lightly resting on her back. "You're mine, aren't you?" You whisper in her ear. "My little slut. My little bitch. Letting me in all three holes in one session."
She whispers, "Yessss," at each sentence you say and when her ass relaxes, you keep youself on top of her while moving in and out again. You keep whispering things like, "My slut. Sam's my slut. You'll do whatever I want. You're mine." Again she moans, "Yes," at each sentence and you know it's turning her on so you keep going even though it's making you approach your own cum even faster. "My slut wears dresses or skirts around me. My slut doesn't wear panties under them. My slut is always available." She doesn't balk but keeps saying, "Yes." So you go for broke, so to speak. "My slut knows she can't openly be my girlfriend. My slut knows she won't be my only one. My slut won't be jealous. My slut will happily share me with my other sluts. My slut will have my babies. My slut will help with my other babies."
You aren't sure if she's just in the moment or really means it every time she says, "Yes," but it's clear the thoughts are turning her on as much as it does you because she cums hard again at your last sentence and you can't hold back any more. You cum hard into her ass and are so drained of energy that your whole weight slumps against Sam. She is able to hold you up for just a second before her own arms lose the battle and she falls to the bed. You follow her down and when she hits the bed, you knock the breath out of each other.
You lie there on top of her, your dick still inside her ass, until you recover enough to realize she's out of breath as well so you move off her and your dick slips out. "That was awesome," you whisper. She nods her head at you while gasping for breath.
There's a look in her eye that you haven't seen before, a look that it takes you a minute or two to interpret. |